Microgreens

Microgreens vs Mature Greens (and Spinach and Kale): The Numbers

In the microgreens vs mature greens debate, the best data comes from a 2012 study of 25 microgreens. USDA scientists helped run it. Gram for gram, the tiny leaves had more of several vitamins than grown-up leaves. But the amounts varied a lot by crop. And you eat far less of them by weight. Here's what the numbers say.

Microgreens next to a bunch of mature kale and spinach

Short answer: in a study of 25 microgreens, the small leaves had more vitamins C, E and K per gram than grown leaves.1 Red cabbage microgreens had up to 147 mg of vitamin C per 100 g. Raw red cabbage has 57 mg.2 But results vary by crop, and portions are small. Eat both.

What the study found

In 2012, a research team tested 25 microgreens bought from growers.1 Here's what they found:

Nutrient Range in microgreens (per 100 g) Highest
Vitamin C 20.4–147.0 mg Red cabbage
Beta-carotene 0.6–12.1 mg Cilantro
Vitamin K1 60–410 µg Red amaranth (garnet)
Vitamin E (alpha-tocopherol) 4.9–87.4 mg Green daikon radish

The team said the small leaves were more nutrient-dense than grown leaves in the USDA database.

Microgreens vs mature greens: one clear example

Per 100 g Red cabbage microgreens Mature red cabbage, raw
Vitamin C up to 147 mg 57 mg

Sources: microgreen value from Xiao et al., mature value from USDA FoodData Central.12

How they compare to spinach and kale

Mature spinach and kale are already nutrient-dense. Per 100 g raw, USDA data lists:2

Per 100 g raw Spinach Kale Broccoli
Calories 23 35 31
Vitamin C 28 mg 93 mg 91 mg
Vitamin K 483 µg 390 µg 102 µg
Fiber 2.2 g 4.1 g 2.4 g

Some microgreens beat these for certain nutrients per gram. Others don't. Mature kale's vitamin K, for example, is higher than any microgreen in the 2012 study.

The portion problem

Those numbers are per gram. A handful of microgreens weighs much less than a bowl of salad. So, in practice:

  • Microgreens add a concentrated boost of vitamins and flavour.
  • Mature greens add volume, fiber and minerals.

The best plan is both: a bowl of spinach or kale, topped with a generous handful of microgreens.

Why microgreens can be so concentrated

Seedlings pack a lot into small leaves as they start to grow. Light matters too. Microgreens grown in good light build more colour pigments. Harvest time and freshness count as well.

Animal research

In one mouse study, red cabbage microgreens lowered LDL and liver cholesterol in mice fed a high-fat diet.3 That's early animal work. It doesn't prove the same happens in people. Read more in health benefits of microgreens.

Microgreens vs mature greens: the takeaway

Microgreens are a great add-on, not a replacement. Grow a few nutrient-dense crops, such as red cabbage, broccoli, radish and kale, and add them to meals with mature greens. Read microgreens myths for other common claims.

Frequently asked questions

Are microgreens more nutritious than mature greens?

Per gram, many microgreens have higher concentrations of some vitamins and carotenoids than mature leaves, according to a USDA-led study. But results vary by crop and nutrient, and people usually eat smaller portions of microgreens.

Are microgreens 40 times more nutritious?

That claim oversimplifies the research. The study found higher concentrations of some nutrients in many microgreens, with a wide range between crops. It didn't find that every microgreen beats every mature green across the board.

Can microgreens replace spinach or kale?

They can be part of the mix, but not a full swap. A cup of spinach or kale weighs much more than a handful of microgreens, so mature greens still add a lot of fiber and minerals.

Which microgreen is the most nutritious?

In the USDA study, red cabbage was highest in vitamin C, cilantro in carotenoids, garnet amaranth in vitamin K, and green daikon radish in vitamin E. No single microgreen led in everything.

Michael

Written by Michael

A passionate sprouting professional sharing practical tips for growing sprouts and microgreens at home. More about Michael

Sources

  1. Xiao Z, Lester GE, Luo Y, Wang Q. Assessment of vitamin and carotenoid concentrations of emerging food products: edible microgreens. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2012. Link
  2. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. FoodData Central (SR Legacy and Foundation Foods), values per 100 g. Link
  3. Huang H, et al. Red cabbage microgreens lower circulating LDL, liver cholesterol, and inflammatory cytokines in mice fed a high-fat diet. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, 2016. Link